God's Sovereignty in Israel's Kingship and Monarchy

God's sovereignty over Israel's kingship and monarchy is a central theme throughout the Old Testament, emphasizing that while human kings ruled, their authority was always subordinate to God's ultimate dominion ^[6]. The very name "Israel" signifies "who prevails with God," hinting at a divine relationship that undergirds the nation's existence and leadership ^[3].

The concept of God's sovereignty is foundational, asserting that God alone is the ultimate authority and there is no other God besides Him ^[4]. This doctrine is presented as a fundamental truth intended to abolish idolatry ^[4]. As the "Lord thy God," God possesses inherent authority and dominion, establishing laws for the governance of His people, Israel, based on both natural claim and covenantal relationship ^[5]. This divine right to establish laws is evident in the giving of the Ten Commandments, which are presented as God's sovereign pronouncements ^[5].

Even when Israel transitioned from a judgeship to a monarchy, God's supreme rule remained paramount. Hezekiah, in his prayer, acknowledged that because the Lord is the Creator, He is the God of all the kingdoms of the earth, sovereign over them all ^[7]. The cherubim, located atop the Ark of the Covenant in the Temple, symbolized God's throne, further illustrating His kingship over Israel ^[7]. The Psalms frequently celebrate God's supremacy in creation and providence, describing Him as a King entering His reign, clothed in the glorious attributes of His nature, which ensures the world's durability ^[9]. Psalm 67:35 declares, "Date gloriam Deo super Israël ; magnificentia ejus et virtus ejus in nubibus" (Give glory to God over Israel; his magnificence and his power are in the clouds) ^[1].

While human kings like Solomon reigned "over all Israel" ^[11], their rule was understood to be under God's overarching power. Calvin notes that while kings, princes, and magistrates hold dominion, they do so "so as to be subject to God, and to owe to him all their power and authority" ^[6]. This perspective is crucial for understanding the nature of Israelite monarchy; the human king was not an absolute ruler but a steward under God.

The historical accounts of Israel's kings often highlight the consequences of adhering to or departing from God's divine law. For instance, King Jehoshaphat of Judah "observed with scrupulous fidelity" the divine institutions established by Moses, rejecting the "spurious and unlawful calf-worship" prevalent in Israel ^[8]. His adherence to God's law resulted in God's blessing on his government, demonstrating that the stability and success of the monarchy were directly tied to its obedience to divine sovereignty ^[8]. The "times that went over him, and over Israel and over all the kingdoms of the earth" were ultimately under God's control, as recorded in 1 Chronicles 29:30 ^[2].

The prophetic tradition further reinforces God's sovereignty over earthly kings. The prophet Isaiah, for example, emphasizes God's "sole and sovereign dominion" which He intended to manifest through His actions concerning Cyrus ^[4]. Even when foreign kings like Sennacherib made false claims, Hezekiah recognized that the Lord, as Creator, was the true God of Israel and sovereign over all kingdoms ^[7]. The vision of "the God of Israel" seen by the elders, similar to Isaiah's vision of the Lord sitting on His throne, underscores the reality of God's heavenly kingship ^[10].

Even during periods of national crisis, such as the Babylonian captivity, the covenant of royalty with David and his seed, along with the priesthood and the covenant of peculiarity with Abraham, were understood to be temporarily interrupted but not ultimately broken ^[12]. The promise was that these covenants would "take place again," with their true meaning fulfilled in the New Testament, signifying God's enduring sovereignty over the lineage and destiny of Israel's kingship ^[12]. This demonstrates that God's plan for Israel's monarchy was not contingent on the unbroken success of human kings but on His own eternal purpose.

Sources

Psalms “Date gloriam Deo super Israël ; magnificentia ejus et virtus ejus in nubibus. -- Psalms 67:35”
I Chronicles “I Chronicles 29:30 (Geneva1599) — With all his reigne and his power, and times that went ouer him, and ouer Israel and ouer all the kingdomes of the earth.”
Hitchcock's Bible Names “Hitchcock's Bible Names: Israel — who prevails with God”
Isaiah (Nonconformist/Puritan) “Matthew Henry on Isaiah 45:5: God here asserts his sole and sovereign dominion, as that which he designed to prove and manifest to the world in all the great things he did for Cyrus and by him. Observe, I. How this doctrine is here laid down concerning the sovereignty of the great Jehovah, in two things: - 1. That he is God alone, and there is no God besides him. This is here inculcated as a fundamental truth, which, if it were firmly believed, would abolish idolatry out of the world. With what an awful, commanding, air of majesty and authority, bidding defiance, as it were, to all pretenders,”
Deuteronomy (Presbyterian) “Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on Deuteronomy 5:6: I am the Lord thy God--The word "Lord" is expressive of authority or dominion; and God, who by natural claim as well as by covenant relation was entitled to exercise supremacy over His people Israel, had a sovereign right to establish laws for their government. [See on Exo 20:2.] The commandments which follow are, with a few slight verbal alterations, the same as formerly recorded (Exo. 20:1-17), and in some of them there is a distinct reference to that promulgation.”
CCEL (Reformed) “Calvin, Commentary on Isaiah, Vol. 3, section 5.20: manner without restraining his insolence; for Sennacherib claims for himself what belonged to God, and at length would not pass unpunished. The statement, that all the kingdoms of the earth are under the power and authority of God, applies especially to the present subject. Yet while this title always belongs to God alone, that he “rules over all kingdoms,” Still the Prophet does not deny that kings also, and princes, and magistrates hold their dominion, but so as to be subject to God, and to owe to him all their power and authority. In like ”
Isaiah (Protestant academic) “Tyndale House on Isaiah 37:16: 37:16 God of Israel: Hezekiah was not taken in by the false claims of Sennacherib that the Lord was powerless. In his prayer, Hezekiah acknowledged that, because the Lord is the Creator, he is God of all the kingdoms of the earth. The Lord is sovereign over all kingdoms. • The mighty cherubim were located in the Temple atop the Ark of the Covenant, which was God’s throne in his Temple (see study note on Lev 16:2; see also Pss 80:1; 99:1).”
2 Chronicles (Presbyterian) “Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on 2 Chronicles 17:4: and not after the doings of Israel--He observed with scrupulous fidelity, and employed his royal influence to support the divine institutions as enacted by Moses, abhorring that spurious and unlawful calf-worship that now formed the established religion in Israel. Being thus far removed, alike from gross idolatry and Israelitish apostasy, and adhering zealously to the requirements of the divine law, the blessing of God rested on his government. Ruling in the fear of God, and for the good of his subjects, "the Lord established the kingdom in his h”
Psalms (Presbyterian) “Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on Psalms 92 (introduction): This and the six following Psalms were applied by the Jews to the times of the Messiah. The theme is God's supremacy in creation and providence. (Psa 93:1-5) God is described as a King entering on His reign, and, for robes of royalty, investing Himself with the glorious attributes of His nature. The result of His thus reigning is the durability of the world.”
Sefaria (Jewish (Rationalist)) “Abraham Ibn Ezra on Exodus 24:10: AND THEY SAW THE GOD OF ISRAEL. In a prophetic vision. It is similar to I saw the Lord sitting on His throne (I Kings 22:19; II Chron. 18:18).”
1 Kings (Presbyterian) “Jamieson, Fausset & Brown on 1 Kings 4 (introduction): SOLOMON'S PRINCES. (Kg1 4:1-6) So King Solomon was king over all Israel--This chapter contains a general description of the state and glory of the Hebrew kingdom during the more flourishing or later years of his reign.”
Jeremiah (Nonconformist/Puritan) “Matthew Henry on Jeremiah 33:17: Three of God's covenants, that of royalty with David and his seed, that of the priesthood with Aaron and his seed, and that of Peculiarity with Abraham and his seed, seemed to be all broken and lost while the captivity lasted; but it is here promised that, notwithstanding that interruption and discontinuance for a time, they shall all three take place again, and the true intents and meaning of them all shall be abundantly answered in the New Testament blessings, typified by those conferred on the Jews after their return out of captivity. I. The covenant of roya”

Ask Your Own Question